Shelby Oaks

My nephew joined me once again for Shelby Oaks, the final movie in my epic triple feature yesterday.  Writer/director Chris Stuckmann is a popular YouTube movie critic (I often watch his channel) who made this movie by fundraising on Kickstarter so I was really intrigued and excited to see it.  Unfortunately, I found it to be a jumbled and derivative mess despite an interesting premise and a strong beginning.  Riley Brennan (Sarah Durn) hosted the popular YouTube series "Paranormal Paranoids" with her friends David (Eric Francis Melaragni), Peter (Anthony Baldasare), and Laura (Caisey Cole) before the four of them disappeared while investigating the ghost town Shelby Oaks twelve years earlier.  Three of them were eventually found dead but Mia Brennan (Camille Sullivan) still believes that her sister Riley is alive.  She is interviewed about her search for her sister for a true crime documentary which also includes footage from one of the group's cameras showing a terrified Riley right before she disappeared.  After Mia discovers a second camera which shows footage of an abandoned prison in Shelby Oaks, she conducts research about a prisoner named Wilson Miles (Charlie Talbert) which leads her to his dilapidated cabin and answers about what happened to Riley.  I really liked the mockumentary structure because it presents the backstory about the disappearance in a way that I found very compelling.  I also liked the use of found footage because it is very atmospheric and unsettling.  However, when the narrative shifts to Mia's investigation in Shelby Oaks, it loses focus and momentum and I became less engaged.  This is obviously an homage to Stuckmann's favorite horror movies but, with so many references to movies such as The Blair Witch Project, Rosemary's Baby, The Omen, and Hereditary (to name a few), the story lacks cohesion and feels incomplete (I actually fell asleep for about five minutes and it felt like I missed an hour's worth of plot development).  Finally, so much of what happens strains credulity with Mia making bad decision after bad decision just to advance the plot (including an incomprehensible one that leads to an incredibly unsatisfying ending).  I really wanted to like this after rooting for Stuckmann to get it made for so long but I cannot recommend it.