Finding Neverland at HCT

I don't think I have ever had a more emotional response to a show than than the one I had when I saw Finding Neverland on Broadway (I was crying my eyes out by the end) so I was beyond excited when it was announced as part of the 2025 season at HCT and I have been eagerly awaiting my chance to see it ever since (I've also been recommending it to all of my theatre friends). I went to a matinee yesterday afternoon and, while I thoroughly enjoyed it, I feel like it is missing some of the magic of the Broadway production. J.M. Barrie (Keith McKay Evans) is a playwright suffering from writers' block, much to the chagrin of his snobby society wife Mary (Jordyn Aspyn Durfey) and his exasperated theatre director Charles Frohman (Alex King), when he meets the Llewelyn Davies brothers, George (Lucas Huizingh), Jack (Andrew Laudie), Peter (Flynn Mitchell), and Michael (Link Evans), and their mother Sylvia (Amy Shreeve Keeler), in Kensington Gardens. The Llewelyn Davies family, especially Sylvia and Peter, help him find his imagination again and inspires him to write the play Peter Pan while Barrie helps Sylvia, who is sick, and Peter, who is still mourning the loss of his father, learn that you shouldn't take life too seriously. I really love all of the music in this show but I was especially impressed by Evans' passionate rendition of "My Imagination" and Keeler's powerful performance of "All That Matters" (they both have beautiful voices) and their chemistry is palpable in "Neverland" and "What You Mean to Me."  I loved the innovative staging of "Believe," when Barrie and the brothers fly around Kensington Gardens in a giant paper boat, "Circus of Your Mind," when ticking clocks (which represent the people who disapprove of Barrie) are transformed into a giant crocodile, "Stronger," when Barrie's alter ego Captain Hook takes him to a pirate ship to encourage him to be bolder, and "What You Mean to Me," as Barrie and Sylvia dance with their shadows (performed by aerialists Lance Nielson and Samantha Nielson). I also enjoyed seeing Peter Pan (Tyson Russell) fly around Barrie in certain scenes because he represents Barrie. The stage is brilliantly configured as a series of giant books with projections of text all around the theatre and many of the set pieces, which come in from the wings, up from the pit, and down from the rafters, look like line drawings (I especially liked the duvets on the beds in the nursery). The period costumes are gorgeous, especially all of Sylvia's gowns and Captain Cook's elaborate frock coat. However, with the exception of Shelby Maughan, who plays Mr. Henshaw, and Colton James Kraus, who plays Mr. Cromer, I found the acting troupe to be very bland (they are completely over-the-top in the Broadway production) so the songs "The World Is Upside Down," "Something About This Night," and "Neverland (Reprise)" are a bit underwhelming. To be fair, I attended a matinee with many empty seats (my whole row was empty) so that may have affected the energy. Finally, I waited with great anticipation for the penultimate scene with Sylvia because, in the Broadway production, it is one of the most magical bits of stage craft that I have ever seen and, honestly, I was disappointed with this version because I found it a bit pedestrian (I expected more from Dave Tinney and all of the bells and whistles from a state-of-the-art stage). There is actually a lot to love about HCT's version and my comparison to the Broadway production is probably unfair so I definitely think it is worth seeing. It runs on the Young Living Centre Stage through June 14 (go here for tickets) but act quickly because many shows are sold out.

Note:  A huge shout-out to Indy, who is making her acting debut as the Barries' dog Porthos, because she is adorable and she does such a great job!