Mary Poppins at the Terrace Plaza Playhouse

I really love the musical Mary Poppins so I've been looking forward to seeing it at the Terrace Plaza Playhouse for quite some time. I had the opportunity last night and, other than some wonderful performances from the main cast, I though it was a very amateur production that was often disorganized and messy. Mary Poppins (Annie Ferrin) comes to 17 Cherry Tree Lane to look after Jane and Michael Banks (Daphne Dixon and Owen Talbot, respectively) but, after a few adventures with Bert the chimney sweep (Josh Curtis) to teach them a lesson, she ends up saving their father, George Banks (Jon Talbot), as well. I really enjoyed Ferrin's performance as Mary because she has a beautiful voice, especially in "Practically Perfect," "A Spoonful of Sugar,"and "Feed the Birds," and she has wonderful chemistry with Dixon and Talbot, who are adorable as the Banks children, especially when she is being stern with them.  Curtis is extremely charismatic as Bert and I really liked all of his facial expressions. Talbot is quite sympathetic as Mr. Banks, even when he is being disagreeable, and Karlie Ady portrays Mrs. Banks's character arc from a woman who does not know her role to one who provides strength for her family very well. While the main cast is outstanding, there are some additions to the cast that seemed very odd to me. There are a trio of characters in colored costumes with hair to match (they reminded me of the fairies in Sleeping Beauty) who seem to serve no purpose other than standing around (or sitting) on stage. Even more perplexing are the toys (a Raggedy Andy, teddy bear, ballerina, and toy soldier) that come to life when Mary has the children clean the nursery and appear throughout the entire show with their stuffed counterparts rather than briefly during "Playing the Game" as they usually do (I could never figure out what they were doing). The ensemble is incredibly large and even seems to include the very young children of ensemble members (who do nothing but stand there and look cute). It is almost as if anyone who auditioned was allowed to be a part of the show. The choreography for the big song and dance numbers "Jolly Holiday" and "Supercalifragilisticexpialidocious" is really good but the staging, with so many cast members on such a small stage, is chaotic. I was sitting in one of the side sections and I could hardly see Mary, Burt, or the Banks children (who are meant to be the principals in these numbers) because there are so many people blocking them. I was most disappointed by "Step in Time" because it is usually a show-stopper involving Burt, Mary, the Banks children, and the chimney sweeps tap dancing on the roofs of London. In this production the entire cast is used, including the statues from the park, the fairies, the toys (a break dancing teddy bear definitely took me out of the moment), as well as Mr. and Mrs. Banks (which makes no sense because they are supposed to be angry when Mary and the others return through the fireplace) and it is so messy. Once again, I couldn't see Mary or Burt at all which was frustrating. The set consists of the nursery and the bank on either side of the stage above the seats (I am always impressed with how every part of the theater is used) but the sitting room and kitchen are located down stage so the large fireplace and chair block everything that happens up stage.  Furthermore, the chair, inexplicably, faces away from the audience so Mr. Banks is frequently hidden from view. The costumes are great, especially Mary's iconic dress in "Jolly Holiday" and all of the Edwardian dresses worn by the female ensemble, but I do not understand the reasoning behind having Mrs. Banks wear large hoop skirts (a more Victorian silhouette).  Finally, I certainly do not expect a community theater to have the same special effects as the production I saw recently at Tuacahn but this is a show that requires some magic. I do not think it is unreasonable to expect Mary to fly because it is one of her defining characteristics (I've seen high school productions, including Hunter High, with characters flying) but at the very least the kites should fly in "Let's Go Fly a Kite." I know that it sounds like I am being overly harsh but after seeing outstanding productions of Seven Brides for Seven Brothers and The Scarlet Pimpernel at this theater I was definitely expecting more from this show.