The Musical Comedy Murders of 1940 at HCT

Last night I was really excited for The Musical Comedy Murders of 1940 at HCT because I had never seen it before (which is something that doesn't happen very often). It is a hilarious spoof of both the noir detective thrillers and the slapstick comedies that were popular in the 1940s and I had so much fun watching it! A maid named Helsa Wenzel (Kristi Curtis) is murdered (although no one will notice until the end of Act 1) in the library of a mansion in Chappaqua, New York owned by an eccentric theatre impresario named Elsa Von Grossenknueten (Claire Kenny). Elsa has invited Nikki Crandall (Corinne Adair), a young and beautiful singer/dancer, Eddie McCuen (Kyle Baugh), a struggling comedian, and Patrick O'Reilly (Bryan Dayley), an Irish tenor, to the mansion to audition for the creative team behind a new Broadway musical, White House Merry-Go-Round, including the director Ken De La Maize (Zac Zumbrunnen), the composer Roger Hopewell (Dustin Bolt), the librettist Bernice Roth (Jasmine Jackman), and the producer Marjorie Baverstock (Eden Benson). However, it turns out that Ken, Roger, Bernice, and Marjorie were also part of the creative team for the musical Manhattan Holiday during which the "Stage Door Slasher" murdered several women, including Elsa's friend Bebe McAllister. She has assembled everyone together so that an undercover policeman, Michael Kelly (Scott James), can discover the identity of the "Stage Door Slasher" but, instead, there is another murder and Helsa's body is finally discovered. Chaos ensues, including secret passageways, secret identities, and a secret code, until the murderer is revealed! In this production, the plot is presented as a play-within-a-play with an Author (Davey Morrison) who is writing it (with projections of the text on a scrim when the show opens and above the stage periodically during the show) as it is being performed. The Author also speaks all of the stage directions and sometimes interacts with the cast (especially Eddie who is his stand-in during the romantic scenes with Nikki) to great comedic effect. The production design, including the set, the costumes, and the make-up, is incredibly clever and I won't spoil it here because it is such a dramatic reveal! The characters are completely over-the-top and I especially loved the flamboyant Roger and the emotional Bernice because they are constantly bickering with each other as well as Ken because he is so bombastic. The performances are also a lot of fun and the entire cast does a great job with the rapid-fire dialogue and the exaggerated physical comedy. Shout-outs go to Benson for the spectacular way in which she falls out of a chair and Dayley (one of my favorite frequent performers at HCT because he always makes me laugh) for his unhinged facial expressions. I thoroughly enjoyed this because it is both extremely funny and highly original and I definitely recommend it (go here for tickets). It runs on the Sorenson Legacy Jewel Box Stage through November 15 with best availability for the matinees.