Anatomy of a Fall

My nephew has made a lot of new friends in college but, apparently, he has missed going to movies with me (which I think is really sweet) so I arranged for us to see Anatomy of a Fall at the Broadway last night.  This was one of my most anticipated movies from the fall festivals (it won the Palme d'Or at Cannes) and both Sean and I found it to be incredibly thought-provoking.  When Samuel Maleski (Samuel Theis) falls to his death from the attic window of his isolated chalet in the mountains of France, an autopsy is unable to determine is it was an accident or murder.  His German wife Sandra Voyter (Sandra Hüller) becomes the prime suspect because she was the only one home at the time.  She is eventually put on trial when an audio recording of an argument between her and her husband surfaces.  Her lawyer (Swann Arlaud) introduces evidence suggesting a suicide, even though she is very uncomfortable with this defense, but the aggressive public prosecutor (Antoine Reinartz) builds a case, based on a subjective interpretation of the audio recording, showing that the marriage was troubled and that their fights often escalated to violence.  Their young son Daniel (Milo Machado-Graner), who is visually impaired and was out for a walk when his father fell to his death, struggles to make sense of the evidence he hears in court but he must ultimately decide who to believe before he testifies.  This is an incredibly tense courtroom drama made even more so by including a language barrier (Sandra is German and, therefore, not fluent in French so she often lapses into English when testifying) because this creates even more opportunities to misconstrue her meaning.  It is a cautionary tale about the ways in which private moments between two people can appear very differently to others when they become public and I was absolutely riveted!  In fact, Sean and I both came to different conclusions about Sandra's culpability (in my opinion her guilt or innocence almost doesn't matter) and I am still thinking about it!  Hüller gives a brilliant and highly nuanced performance (the Oscar buzz surrounding her is entirely warranted) but Machado-Graner is absolutely amazing because the camera is often on him during the courtroom scenes and his reactions inform the audience how to feel about the various revelations.  Finally, this movie features one of the best uses of a song (an instrumental version of "P.I.M.P" by 50 Cent no less) that I have ever seen because it has multiple meanings and becomes more and more important as the narrative progresses.  Believe the hype about this one!