She Started It

My June Book of the Month selection was She Started It by Sian Gilbert (the other options were The Wishing Game by Meg Shaffer, Ink Blood Sister Scribe by Emma Torzs, Lady Tan's Circle of Women by Lisa See, and Banyan Moon by Thao Thai). I defaulted to the thriller yet again and this twisty page-turner kept me up all night! Former school friends Annabel, Esther, Tanya, and Chloe are surprised when they receive invitations to an all-expenses-paid bachelorette weekend from Poppy Greer. The four of them often bullied Poppy at school but it was so long ago and she must have forgiven them for their little pranks by now. Besides, who could resist the opportunity to stay at a luxury resort on a private island in the Bahamas? They are discomfited to discover that they are Poppy's only guests but soon settle in for three days of sun, sand, and cocktails. However, it soon becomes clear that Poppy has arranged this weekend to exact revenge but, when one of the four is murdered, Poppy is not the only one with a motive. The narrative alternates between the POVs of Annabel, Esther, Tanya, and Chloe in the present and Poppy's diary entries about past events when they were at school. The four main characters are unlikable and unreliable narrators with lots of secrets that are revealed little by little and the diary entries cleverly inform what is happening on the island and why (although the diary entries read as if they are a creative writing project rather than the words of a young girl). The suspense builds and builds as the island is transformed from a tropical paradise into a literal prison with no way to communicate with the outside world and no way to leave. The plot is quite ingenious (I especially enjoyed how Poppy uses technology to get even with her tormentors) and there are so many twists and turns (it is really fun when the women begin turning on one another) that I actually suspected everyone at one point! I did figure out one of the biggest twists before the big reveal but it didn't detract from my enjoyment because the story is so engaging that I raced through to find out if I was right and I giggled out loud when something happened to confirm my suspicions. This is a quick and easy read that combines Mean Girls with The Lord of the Flies and I recommend it for fans of thrillers.