A Gentleman's Guide to Love and Murder at HCTO

I recently had the chance to see A Gentleman's Guide to Love and Murder at the Empress Theatre and I was very impressed by what they did with an incredibly ambitious show in such a small and intimate space.  Because HCTO is similar in scale I was really eager to see their version and I had the opportunity last night.  I was equally impressed by this production!  After the death of his mother, Monty Navarro (Jordan Nicholes) is informed by her friend Miss Shingle (Bonnie Wilson-Whitlock) that she was once a member of the wealthy and aristocratic D'Ysquith family but was disinherited for marrying his father.  He is really Montague D'Ysquith Navarro and he is in line to inherit an earldom.  However, there are eight family members ahead of him!  When his vain and heartless girlfriend Sibela (Brittany Sanders) marries the rich and handsome Lionel Holland, he decides to murder all eight family members in order to become the Earl of Highhurst and win her back.  Standing in his way are the Reverend Lord Ezekiel D'Ysquith (who has an unfortunate fall from the bell tower of his cathedral), Asquith D'Ysquith, Jr. (who has a bizarre skating accident), Henry D'Ysquith (who is stung by bees), Lady Hyacinth D'Ysquith (who disappears in deepest darkest Africa and is presumed dead), Major Lord Bartholomew D'Ysquith (who is decapitated while lifting weights), Lady Salome D'Ysquith Pomphrey (who is killed when a prop gun is mistakenly loaded with real bullets during her debut in Hedda Gabbler), Lord Asquith D'Ysquith, Sr. (who is driven to a heart attack after hearing about all of the deaths in his family), and, finally, Lord Adalbert D'Ysquith, the Earl of Highhurst, (who is mysteriously poisoned).  Along the way, Monty falls in love with Phoebe D'Ysquith (Lisa Zimmerman) and marries her which makes Sibela jealous.  When Monty becomes the Earl of Highhurst he is arrested for the murder of Adalbert, the only D'Ysquith death for which he is actually not responsible!  The charges are eventually dismissed when Phoebe and Sibela each give proof that the other committed the murder but Monty might not live happily after because Chauncey D'Ysquith, the next in line to the earldom, is lurking!  The cast is absolutely stellar and I particularly enjoyed both Wilson-Whitlock and Laurel Asay Lowe (as Lady Eugenia D'Ysquith) because their characters are so unhinged!  However, the star of the show is Bryan Dayley who plays every member of the D'Ysquith family (I loved him in a similar role in One For The Pot at HCT last year).  He is absolutely hilarious and makes every character feel distinct with his facial expressions and comedic physicality (as well as some quick costume changes).  Every time I see this show I always love a different family member and this time my favorites were the Reverend Ezekiel (because of the way he flails about before he falls) and Lord Adalbert (because of his plummy accent).  As with most productions of this show, the set is reminiscent of an old music hall but I loved the use of a falling red curtain in between scene changes and the elaborate painted backdrops.  A scene where Monty must keep Sibela and Phoebe apart at his flat is staged in an especially clever way and I also loved the singing ancestors at Highhurst.  Finally the period costumes are incredible, especially the highly embellished gowns worn by Sibela and Phoebe!  Do yourself a favor and get a ticket to this hilarious show (go here).  It runs through April 8 but many dates are sold out!