We Are the Brennans

My Book of the Month selection for July was We Are the Brennans by Tracey Lange (the other options were Sisters in Arms by Kaia Alderson, Razorblade Tears by S. A. Cosby, The People We Keep by Allison Larkin, and 56 Days by Catherine Ryan Howard) and I really loved it. In fact, I stayed up reading into the early morning hours several times because I was so riveted by the story. Sunday Brennan wakes up in a Los Angeles hospital room with severe injuries from a car accident after a night of drinking. She eventually decides to return home to New York to be with her close-knit Irish-Catholic family to recover and deal with her legal situation. However, it turns out that she abandoned her father Mickey, her brothers Denny, Jackie, and Shane, and her fiance Kale (who has since married someone else) and fled to California five years ago without explanation after a traumatic incident and has never spoken to them about it. She tries to reconnect with her loved ones but she is not the only one who has been keeping secrets and the repercussions of her secret threaten to destroy the happiness and security of all of the Brennans. The family members love each other fiercely and they think that sparing each other from any unpleasantness is an act of kindness but it is driving them apart. Ultimately, they must learn to trust each other to get through their problems together. This family is incredibly dysfunctional and each character makes terrible decisions but I still found them all to be very sympathetic. The family dynamic feels authentic because it is informed by Lange's own experiences growing up with a large Irish-Catholic family and the interactions between the family members are both humorous and heart-breaking (and incredibly relatable). I was the most invested in the relationship between Sunday, Kale, and his wife Vivienne because it is so awkward, especially when Sunday and Kale realize they still have feelings for each other, and it is tragic because they could be together if they had only communicated with each other. The narrative alternates between multiple perspectives and Lange uses the device of ending a chapter with a conversation that is picked up in the next chapter by a different POV which is incredibly effective at drawing in the reader because I literally couldn't put this book down! It seems like a new secret is revealed in every chapter, several of which really surprised me, and I really appreciated the fact that every problem isn't magically solved in the end but the resolution still feels incredibly hopeful. If you love a good generational saga as much as I do, I highly recommend We Are the Brennans.