Summer Reading: The Witch Elm

The next selection on my summer reading list, The Witch Elm by Tana French, is an intense psychological character study that challenged me to think and that is the best kind of book, in my opinion! Toby Hennessy has always thought of himself as lucky. He is good-looking, intelligent, and charismatic enough to talk himself out of any tricky situation. He has a group of loyal friends, a devoted girlfriend, and a supportive extended family of means. However, after a night of drinking with his mates, his luck changes because he is attacked during a burglary attempt on his flat and suffers a catastrophic brain injury. He takes refuge at his family's ancestral home on the outskirts of Dublin with his uncle Hugo and cousins Leon and Susannah to care for him. While he is recuperating there, a body with connections to everyone in the house is found buried in the wych elm tree in the garden. As the murder is investigated, Toby comes to question everything he thought about himself, his family, and his upbringing. The narrative starts very slowly as Toby struggles to overcome the physical and psychological trauma he has endured but this becomes very relevant as the murder mystery unfolds. It was difficult to plod through the beginning but once the action gets going I was absolutely riveted. Toby is the ultimate unreliable narrator because his charmed existence made him oblivious to events surrounding the murder of his former classmate and his brain injury makes his own memories suspect. This adds greatly to the suspense. French's writing style, in this particular novel, is very cerebral with long meditative passages so it might not be for everyone. I enjoyed it because it made me think about how we view ourselves compared to how others view us, what role memory plays in our view of ourselves, and how our actions have consequences that reverberate far more than we imagine. It is a brilliant character study that takes some effort to get thorough but is ultimately worth the trouble.

Note:  Have you read The Witch Elm?  What did you think?