Water for Elephants at the Eccles

Last night I went to the Broadway touring production of Water for Elephants at the Eccles (it was the last show of the 2025-2026 season). I loved the book by Sara Gruen and I liked the movie starring Robert Pattinson, Reese Witherspoon, and Christoph Waltz so I was eager to see where the stage adaptation would land. After losing his parents in a car accident and his childhood home to foreclosure, Jacob Jankowski (Zachary Keller) is forced to drop out of veterinary school and hops a train going anywhere in Depression-era America. It turns out that the train belongs to the Benzini Brothers Circus and he is reluctantly put to work as a laborer. However, his knowledge of animals soon comes in handy and he is asked to care for an ailing horse named Silver Star, who he cannot save, and then a stubborn elephant named Rosie. August Rackinger (Connor Sullivan), the cruel and sadistic ringmaster, wants Rosie to become the new star attraction but Jacob falls in love with his wife Marlena (Helen Krushinski) as they train the elephant together. August eventually abuses both Rosie and Marlena but, before Jacob can intervene to save Marlena, Rosie uses the bullhook that August beat her with to kill him during a stampede (because an elephant never forgets). The narrative is told through flashbacks by an older Jacob (Robert Tully) who escapes from his assisted living home to join the circus again. I have to admit that when I first heard about this adaptation I wondered if the story was strong enough to warrant a musical treatment and, unfortunately, the answer is no in my opinion. The script is definitely the weakest link because the plot of the book (which is mostly internal dialogue) is simplified and Jacob is the only character that has any development or backstory.  There are also several subplots that are introduced and then quickly abandoned. In addition, the songs are not particularly memorable (I struggled to remember any of the titles while writing this). Having said that, everyone in the cast does an incredible job with all of the musical numbers. Keller and Krushinski, especially, have beautiful voices and their renditions of "Silver Stars" and "Easy," respectively, are highlights of the show. They both also give a moving performance of "Wild." Sullivan has an imposing stature and his powerful versions of "The Lion Has Got No Teeth" and "You've Got Nothing" are quite menacing and emphasize August's volatile nature. Shoutouts also go to Javier Garcia as Camel, Tyler West as Walter, Grant Huneycutt as Wade, and Ruby Gibbs as Barbara because they each have a moment to shine. However, the insanely talented acrobats, jugglers, contortionists, and aerialists (Nancy Luna, Yves Artieres, Fran Alvarez Jara, Ella Huestis, Serafina Walker, and John Neurohr) are absolutely spectacular and make this show worth the price of admission. All of the circus acts are visually stunning and I was especially impressed by a breathtaking aerial performance on white silks by Artieres, who portrays the horse Silver Star, in the number "Easy" (this actually brought tears to my eyes). The colorful costumes, lighting design, and projections create a circus-like atmosphere and the metal set pieces used to represent the train cars are very clever. Finally, the puppets used for the menagerie of animals are very striking. I was a bit disappointed with the puppet for Rosie in the first act because you can only see parts of her or just her shadow but then she is revealed in her entirety in a show-stopping moment (literally because it ends the first act) after Jacob and Marlena are able to communicate with her and I loved this choice once I realized what it meant! I also loved that the puppeteers are dressed in nondescript coveralls when Rosie is training but in sequins when she is performing. There are flaws but I highly recommend this for the performances and the spectacle. It runs at the Eccles Theatre through August 30 and tickets may be purchased here.