Arsenic and Old Lace at HCTO

Last night I went to see Arsenic and Old Lace at HCTO and I could not stop laughing at this classic madcap comedy!  Two elderly spinsters, Abby and Martha Brewster (Jayne Luke and Melany Wilkins, respectively), are known in their Brooklyn neighborhood for their numerous acts of charity.  However, their charity includes poisoning lonely old men who come to their home looking for lodging with their homemade elderberry wine.  Their nephew Teddy (Josh Needles), who believes that he is Teddy Roosevelt, helps them by burying the men in the holes he digs for the Panama Canal in the cellar.  Chaos ensues when their other nephew Mortimer (Jon Liddiard) discovers one of their victims in the window seat and when their estranged nephew Jonathan (Matt Kohler) suddenly appears wanting to dispose of one his own victims in the same window seat.  It takes an unwilling accomplice (Jonathan McBride), a bumbling policeman who really wants to be a playwright (BJ Oldroyd), and a curious fiance (Brianna Meikle) to end the mayhem!  What I loved most about this production is the over the top performances, particularly Liddiard because he is hilariously overwrought and Kohler because he is such a melodramatic villain (his facial expressions killed me), and all of the physical comedy, especially every time Teddy charges up the stairs while fighting the Battle of San Juan Hill, when Mortimer gets tangled up in the phone cord, when both Teddy and Dr. Einstein struggle getting the bodies out of the window seat (I sat near the window seat so I had a great view of the shenanigans), and when Officer O'Hara describes the plot of his play in detail.  The set features the kind of fussy drawing room that you would expect two elderly spinsters to inhabit and I loved the all of the details (my favorites of which were the Victorian portrait on the wall near where I was sitting and the red velvet sofa).  The elaborate costumes worn by the Brewster sisters are very amusing because they are in sharp contrast to those worn by the other characters and I laughed out loud when they appeared in black bombazine gowns and veils to conduct the funeral service for their victim.  This is one of the most performed plays for a reason and this particular production is very well done.  I loved it and I highly recommend getting a ticket for a fun night out (go here).  It runs through September 21.